LIS Programs & the Need for Dialogue

I feel lucky to have grown up in Miami, a primarily Hispanic city, where I am not very different from any other Hispanic American. However, as I have grown and traveled across the country, that has changed. What I look like is politics.

The color of my skin and the second language I speak are judged in ways that I cannot control. During a road trip from Miami, Florida to Seattle, Washington I could see the way people reacted to me, the looks they gave, and felt uncomfortable. I thought, if I am feeling this way, what are patrons in different states, in different libraries, all across the country feeling? As information professionals or librarians, in whatever role you play, a big part of your job will be to serve a community. The community may be public, academic, rural, or urban, but I guarantee you it will be filled with people from different races, social classes, age groups, etc. It has become evident that a basic understanding of social issues and the state of the profession is missing from LIS education, and perhaps, in the profession itself.

I thought I was the only one with thoughts on the lack of diversity in libraries until I started to realize, I am not alone. This realization occurred when I met Chris Bourg and an amazing group of people who continue to inspire me daily. I was in the room when Chris spoke about the future of libraries, the same talk that inspired the post; “whiteness, social justice and the future of libraries”. We, as LIS students, as the future of librarianship, need to ask ourselves; how is my program preparing me for librarianship? What are the current issues in librarianship? Why aren’t we having these discussions in class? What can I do to learn more about this? I decided to revive my Twitter account and delved deep into Library Land. I found allies and resources through #CritLib chats, interactions with librarians, and blogs. I followed conference hashtags and other LIS students who introduced me to events like the Diversity, Equity, Race, Accessibility, and Identity in LIS (DERAIL) Forum. I attended virtually and learned about issues that have not been addressed in my core courses, such as ensuring accessibility for disabled or colorblind patrons and serving refugee populations, to name a few.

Nevertheless, I continue to encounter situations reminding me I am part of the 3%* of librarians who are Hispanic, and in this instance, not even part of the equation. *(Librarianship is 88% white) In one of my online courses we were asked to read Daniel Traister’s article, “The Rare Book Librarian’s Day”. It is a short article describing a day in the life of the curator of special collections. It began with this;

“In the autumn of 1975, I entered library school, where I was pleased to find a program especially designed for the preparation of rare book librarians. I was less pleased to hear my instructor inform my class, at its first meeting, that jobs in rare books generally went to rich WASP males. But I am a baseball fan and know that .333 is a respectable major league batting average. So, even though I failed both “rich” and “WASP,” I gambled on “male” – and, I suppose, I have won my little bet”

According to his instructor, I would have a 0% chance, as I am Hispanic, lower-middle class, and a woman. Not to mention the different obstacles people of color must overcome, and structures we must learn to work within in order to succeed. (A great article by Angela Galvan provides context here.) That week a classmate posted a comment saying that if you want something bad enough, you can achieve it, as Traister did. But not all of us have the same opportunities as a white man, or a white woman, and many people of color are perceived and judged in ways we cannot control that effect those opportunities. Furthermore, as students, I believe it is our job to be critical of the information we receive. I also think that some readings are there to spark conversations. Unfortunately, professors do not get involved in discussion posts so I took it upon myself, to very respectfully, say something. As the saying goes, if you see something, say something.

The reality is that important discussions are taking place, just not in library school, and that is a problem. We need to address this in LIS programs when students first learn the policies, practices, and theory of librarianship. This problem inspired a big, wild, ridiculous question. What if there was an LIS association, specifically for LIS students, where we can voice our concerns and help get the information that library school is not currently teaching? My program does not have an ALA student chapter but with a general LIS chapter we could have those benefits, and have conferences like DERAIL or the Symposium on LIS Education. Either way, let’s start a discussion, both on blackboard and in our programs. Let’s approach things differently when we post our introductory bios and help introduce people to new resources. We need to create a foundation for dialogue within the LIS curriculum. To quote Bell Hooks in Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom;“To engage in dialogue is one of the simplest ways we can begin as teachers, scholars and critical thinkers to cross boundaries, the barriers that may or may not be erected by race, gender, class, professional standing, and a host of other differences.” (pg.130)

Denisse_SolisDenisse Solis is an online MLIS graduate student at Kent State University concentrating on archives, digital preservation, and special collections. She is an ARL Diversity Scholar, and 2016-2017 ALA Spectrum Scholar. Solis graduated from Florida International University with bachelor’s degrees in history, art history, and a certificate in European studies. She works for her alma mater as a copy cataloger and enjoys exercising, reading, traveling, and taking naps with her two cats. Twitter @luna_dee.

Editor’s note: this article was originally published on July 6, 2016.

Image credit: Hirshhorn Sculpture Garden (Wikipedia Commons)

13 replies

    • Yes! I was able to speak with Lettycia from the LA chapter during ALA in Orlando and she told me more about it but its so far into the future I don’t know where i’ll be. I am keeping an eye on it though!


      • REFORMA national conferences (RNC) take several years to plan. This is the 6th. In the meantime REFORMA will meet with ALA in Atlanta in 6 month–January 2017 where there will be much information on RNC 6..
        Established in 1971 as an affiliate of the American Library Association (ALA), REFORMA has actively sought to promote the development of library collections to include Spanish-language and Latino oriented materials; the recruitment of more bilingual and bicultural library professionals and support staff; the development of library services and programs that meet the needs of the Latino community; the establishment of a national information and support network among individuals who share our goals; the education of the U.S. Latino population in regards to the availability and types of library services; and lobbying efforts to preserve existing library resource centers serving the interests of Latinos.
        Here is the REFORMA website with upcoming events.
        I hope REFORMA provides a way to discuss the important issues you bring up in your essay and you will met wonderful committed people who overcome to succeed as leaders nationwide.


        • Thank you so much for this info. I am hoping to make it to Atlanta for Midwinter, i’m working on funding and saving. I am also a member of REFORMA but the FL chapter is not as active. I hope to have more opportunities to get involved as I move forward.


  1. Denisse, thank you for speaking up about this issue. It’s important that we have discussions about the diversity issues of this field and how it impacts us and our careers.


  2. Denisse, yo trabajo at OSU and have been volunteering at IFLA. Your professor Myriam Kahn sent me this posting. I am a diversity scholar as well. If you would like to chat a bit?
    Please feel free to contact me. Thanks for taking the time to discuss these issues in such an open way.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s